How the Medical Freedom Maps are verified
In October 2026 the Open Source Medicine Foundation re-checked every value on these maps and on the Medical Freedom Arbitrage Map. The earlier data had been compiled from general knowledge and secondary trackers and was labelled as verified without per-value sources. That labelling was wrong, and this pass replaces it.
The rule
- A value is shown only if a specific, retrievable source states it: a statute, a regulator’s register or decision, an official list, or a named tracker page for that exact topic. A website homepage never counts.
- Each verified value links to that page and carries a short verbatim quote from it.
- Where sources conflict or the law does not fit a category cleanly, the value is marked sources differ with a note.
- Where no adequate source could be found, the value is shown as Not verified. Nothing is guessed.
- Prices are shown only where a source gives a price for that jurisdiction; otherwise they were removed.
How it was done
Research agents (AI-assisted) looked up each claim, recorded the source URL and a verbatim quote, and gave a verdict: confirmed, corrected, ambiguous or unsupported. A script then fetched every cited page, including rendered pages, their data files and Internet Archive copies, and checked that each quote actually appears there. Quotes the script could not match were read by a second reviewer; quotes that could not be confirmed were discarded, and any value left without evidence became Not verified.
Results
| Dataset | Confirmed | Corrected | Ambiguous | Not verified |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| State law layers (claims) | 1,469 | 515 | 127 | 216 |
| Procedure × jurisdiction records (legal status) | 957 | 512 | 442 | 537 |
Quotes: 8,434 evidence quotes were collected. 7,562 were found on the cited page automatically; a reviewer read the remaining 872 pages and confirmed 807 as written and corrected the wording of 22. 43 could not be confirmed and were discarded, together with any value that depended on them.
Limits
- Narrative text on each record was rewritten to contain only statements the cited sources support, but the automated check confirms the quote, not every sentence; sentence-level support rests on the reviewer’s reading of the page.
- Many national medicine registers cannot be read automatically, so some jurisdictions have many Not verified values.
- Laws change. Each value shows the date it was checked. Confirm with the linked source before relying on it.
- This is research information, not legal or medical advice.
Report an error · the full verification data, including every source and quote, is in the public repository.